TL;DR
- India’s private school sector alone spends thousands of crores annually on school books – a significant portion of which replaces books that are still perfectly usable.
- The average textbook has a functional lifespan of 10 to 15 years. Most Indian school books are used for one academic year, then shelved, then scrapped.
- Annual edition updates, publisher-school arrangements, and the absence of an organised second-hand infrastructure collectively drive this process.
- A functioning circular book economy – where a book moves from one student’s finished year into another’s beginning one – already exists in Germany, Finland, and parts of the UK. India has the scale and the need for it.
- Every book sold to the raddi instead of passed on to the next student is a small failure of infrastructure. That infrastructure is being built.
There is a peculiar kind of waste that goes unnoticed because it happens quietly, at the same time every year, in the private corners of millions of homes.
April arrives. The academic year ends. A child stacks their books – the ones they carried every day for ten months, annotated through two cycles of exams, referenced during every study session before the final papers – and puts them aside. On a shelf. Then a box. Then, eventually, a bag for the raddi wala.
The same scene plays out across tens of millions of Indian households simultaneously. A mountain of books, most of them still structurally sound, intellectually intact, and entirely capable of educating another child, leaves the system. Not through any dramatic act of disposal. Just through the steady, unremarkable logic of a system that has never built a proper alternative.
Here is what makes this strange:
A book is not perishable. It does not spoil between April and June. The Pythagorean theorem explained in a Class 9 Mathematics textbook does not become less true when the calendar flips. The photosynthesis chapter in a Class 7 Science book does not degrade. The comprehension passages in a Class 5 English reader do not expire. The knowledge is identical. The paper is intact. The book is ready to be used again.
And yet, it is not.
The Scale of What We Are Quietly Discarding
To understand the waste, you have to first understand the numbers behind it.
India has approximately 250 million school-going children. Roughly 90 million of them attend private schools, where families are responsible for purchasing books at full retail price, every single year. Conservative estimates put the average annual book spend at ₹6,000 per child in the private school sector – a figure that climbs steeply for ICSE and international curriculum students.
That is ₹54,000 crore spent annually on school books in the private sector alone. Every year. Reset.
Now consider what proportion of that spending goes towards books that could have been second-hand without any reduction in educational quality. For NCERT-aligned subjects – Mathematics, Science, Social Studies, Hindi – the core content changes very rarely. A Class 8 Mathematics NCERT textbook published in 2021 is functionally identical to one published in 2018. The chapter on rational numbers is the same. The exercises are the same. The understanding a student gains from it is the same.
Conservatively, 60 to 70 per cent of books purchased new each year could have been sourced second-hand at 40 to 60 per cent below cover price.
The implied saving – had a functioning second-hand infrastructure existed – runs to somewhere between ₹16,000 and ₹19,000 crore annually.
That is not abstract money. That is the aggregate of millions of individual families spending more than they needed to, because the easier, cheaper option was not organised enough to be accessible.
Also Read: Are Old Books Still Relevant for College Students
Why the Waste Happens: Four Structural Causes
The obvious assumption is that books get thrown away because they wear out. That is rarely the actual reason. The causes are more structural – and more deliberate – than simple wear and tear.
- The annual edition cycle
Publishers release new editions of school textbooks with remarkable regularity. On paper, the justification is curriculum updates, improved explanations, revised exercises. In practice, the changes between consecutive editions of most school textbooks – particularly for Maths and Science at the school level – are often minimal. A rearranged chapter. A slightly reworded definition. A new set of diagrams that is functionally interchangeable with the last.
The real effect of the annual edition update is the invalidation of the previous year’s books. A school booklist that specifies “2024 edition” means the “2023 edition” your older child used is technically non-compliant. The book is perfectly usable. But the system has been designed so that it cannot be officially used.
- Publisher-school tie-ups
In India’s private school ecosystem, many schools have arrangements – formal or informal – with specific publishers. The school prescribes books from Publisher X. Publisher X supplies them through a designated vendor. The margin structure in this arrangement often includes a share for the school.
For parents, the consequence is simple: they cannot easily compare prices, cannot substitute editions, and cannot demonstrate that a second-hand copy from a different source meets the school’s requirements.
The arrangement is designed to be closed.
- The absence of organised infrastructure
There is a distinction worth making between the availability of second-hand books and the accessibility of second-hand books. Available means they exist somewhere. Accessible means a parent in Pune can reliably find the specific Class 7 CBSE Geography book they need, in good condition, at a fair price, in time for the academic year.
India has had some version of the former for decades – informal WhatsApp groups, local raddi shops that double as secondhand booksellers, the occasional notice board in a school corridor. What it has never had, at scale, is the latter.
The result is a market that exists but does not function efficiently enough to become the default. Parents default to new because new is predictable, available everywhere, and carries no risk of the wrong edition.
- The stigma of second-hand
India’s relationship with second-hand goods is complicated by aspiration. In a country where sending a child to a “good school” is one of the most freighted social acts a family can undertake – where the school bag, the uniform, and yes, the books, are all visible signals of intent and sacrifice – buying second-hand carries an unspoken implication – that the family is struggling, that they could not quite manage the full version of the project they set out on.
This stigma is real, it is understandable, and it costs families thousands of rupees a year for no educational benefit. A brand-new book and a well-maintained second-hand copy produce identical exam results. The stigma produces nothing except additional revenue for publishers.
Recommended Read: Saving Money with Used Textbooks: A Student’s Guide
Three Books, Three Fates
To make the abstract concrete, consider three books. Each one is real in type, if not in individual identity.
Book One: The Class 10 NCERT Science Textbook
Priya in Bengaluru used this book through Class 10. She sat her board exams in March. The book is in good condition – some pencil annotations, one dog-eared chapter, cover slightly worn at the spine. She puts it in a box in April. In June, her family sells a bag of old books to the raddi wala. The Science textbook, which cost ₹65 new, sells for about ₹4 as scrap paper. Meanwhile, a family three kilometres away pays ₹65 for a new copy of the identical book.
Total waste produced by this transaction: one perfectly functional book, destroyed for pulp.
Book Two: The Class 12 Chemistry Reference Guide
Aryan in Delhi used this HC Verma for two years of JEE preparation. It is heavily annotated – his margin notes, his own shortcut derivations, the sections he starred as high-priority. He got into his engineering college. The book sits in his room. His parents, not knowing what to do with it, eventually list it in a local Facebook group. They get one inquiry, a low offer, and no follow-through. By December, it goes to the raddi at ₹10 a kilogram.
Somewhere in Jaipur, a student preparing for JEE next year buys a new HC Verma for ₹750. Aryan’s annotated copy – arguably more useful for its marginal notes – is pulp.
Book Three: The NCERT History Set, Classes 6 to 12
These books are the single most cited resource for UPSC Civil Services preparation. A complete set – twelve books – costs approximately ₹800 to ₹1,000 new. For a first-generation UPSC aspirant from a small town in Madhya Pradesh, that is a meaningful sum. But more than the price, the availability is the problem: these books are frequently out of stock at local shops, especially in non-metro areas, especially in the April-to-June window when everyone is looking.
Meanwhile, in a flat in Noida, a UPSC aspirant who cleared her Mains last year has a complete annotated set she no longer needs. She has no easy way to reach the aspirant in Madhya Pradesh. He has no easy way to find her. Both continue with a suboptimal outcome: she disposes of books that have value, he pays full price for books she already had.
These are not exceptional stories. They are representative of a systemic failure to connect supply with demand.
What a Circular Book Economy Actually Looks Like
The phrase gets used in environmental conversations, but its application to books is simpler and more immediate than most circular economy propositions.
A circular book economy means a book’s useful life extends beyond the single student who bought it anew. It moves – from a finished student to a starting one, at a price that recovers value for the seller and reduces cost for the buyer – and it keeps moving until it is genuinely worn out. Only then does it exit the system.
In practical terms, this already exists in several countries, and not just wealthy ones.
- Germany operates a school textbook lending model in most of its federal states. Books are owned by the school, not the student. They are issued at the start of the year, returned at the end, and reused for multiple academic cycles. Families pay a small annual fee – typically between €20 and €50 – rather than purchasing full sets. Books are retired when they are genuinely unusable, not when a new edition appears.
- The United Kingdom’s secondary school system operates similarly for core textbooks, with students borrowing rather than owning. The university second-hand book market is robust and well-organised – certain platforms and campus library sales make used books the default choice for most students.
- Bangladesh, despite significant economic constraints, distributes free textbooks to all primary and secondary students through a national programme – over 350 million books annually. The logistics are imperfect, but the principle is unambiguous: a textbook is part of the educational infrastructure, not a family’s individual financial burden.
India has none of these systems at scale, outside the NCERT subsidy that reaches government school students. The 90 million children in private schools, and their families, are largely on their own.
What India does have is the raw material for a circular book economy:
A vast stock of existing books in reasonably good condition, sitting in homes across the country; a deep financial motivation for families to participate on both the buying and selling side; and a digital infrastructure capable of connecting them, if that infrastructure is built with the right intent and organisation.
The Raddi Calculation That Should Bother Everyone
Here is a number worth sitting with.
The average family with two private school children in a mid-range CBSE school spends approximately ₹15,000 to ₹20,000 on books annually across both children. Over a twelve-year school career, that is ₹1.8 lakh to ₹2.4 lakh spent on books alone.
At the end of it, those books – the complete accumulated library of a child’s education – are sold to the raddi at ₹8 to ₹12 per kilogram. A full set of twelve years’ school books, the physical record of an entire education, weighs perhaps 30 to 40 kilograms. Its raddi value: ₹300 to ₹480.
The family spent upwards of ₹1.8 lakh. They recovered ₹400. The rest – the value embedded in those books – was transferred to the paper recycling industry, which will use it to make packaging, newsprint, or more books that will eventually go through the same cycle.
This is not an argument against recycling. It is an argument for the step that should come before recycling: reuse. A book does not need to be pulped to be given a second life. It needs an organised way to find its next reader.
Also Read: The Rise of Online Raddiwala
What BookMandee is Building
BookMandee is not trying to solve the publisher-school arrangement problem or the annual edition cycling problem through confrontation. Those are structural issues that will require policy attention alongside market pressure, and they will take time.
What BookMandee is building is the part of the solution that does not require policy to change: the infrastructure that connects the family with books they have finished with to the family that needs them.
This is a marketplace, but organised specifically around academic books – by board, by class, by subject, by edition year. A parent looking for a Class 9 CBSE Chemistry book does not have to scroll through irrelevant listings. A seller’s specific book can reach the specific buyer who needs it.
Every transaction on this platform is a small refusal of the waste described above. A book listed and sold instead of bagged for the raddi. A book bought second-hand instead of purchased new at full price. The seller recovers real money. The buyer saves real money. The book does the job it was made to do – educating a student – for another year.
At scale, this is what a circular book economy looks like from the ground up. Not a government programme. Not a charity initiative. A market that works the way markets should: efficiently connecting supply with demand, at prices that work for both sides, in a way that makes the sensible choice the easy one.
India’s students have never needed more books than they already have. What they have needed is a system that makes those books findable.
What You Can Do Before the Next Academic Year
If you have finished books from the last cycle, the most useful thing you can do is not wait for a more convenient moment to list them on BookMandee. The April to June window is when demand peaks – incoming students looking for exactly what outgoing students have finished with. A book listed in May will sell faster and at a better price than the same book listed in August.
If you are buying books for the next academic year, the most useful question to ask before walking into a bookshop is: does this book need to be new?
For NCERT-aligned textbooks in Classes 1 through 8, the answer is almost never yes. For reference books and competitive exam preparation material, the answer is almost always no. The knowledge inside a well-maintained second-hand copy is identical.
The system will not change on its own. It will change when enough families decide – separately but collectively – that a book’s value is in what it teaches, not in whether it has ever been opened before.
That shift is already happening.
Frequently Asked Questions
If a book has been used, is it genuinely as effective educationally?
For the vast majority of school subjects, yes – completely. The content of NCERT-aligned textbooks in core subjects changes minimally between editions and not at all within the same edition year. A student learning from a well-maintained second-hand copy covers the same syllabus, works through the same exercises, and develops the same understanding as one with a new copy. The paper is different; the education is the same.
How do I know if a second-hand book is the right edition?
Check the edition year against your school’s booklist before purchasing. On BookMandee, listings include edition year, board, class, and subject – so you can verify directly. For NCERT books, edition differences across recent years are almost always negligible in content terms, but it is worth confirming with the school if uncertain.
What is the realistic resale value of a school book in good condition?
Typically 35 to 60 per cent of the cover price, depending on subject, class, condition, and the time of year. Books listed in April to June, during peak demand, sell faster and at better prices. Reference books and competitive exam preparation materials – HC Verma, DC Pandey, NCERT complete sets – often retain particularly strong resale value. To get an estimate, use our price estimate calculator.
Are there subjects where second-hand books are less advisable?
English literature and language books warrant closer checking, since prescribed texts sometimes change annually. For all other subjects at the school level, second-hand copies from the same or immediately preceding edition may be suitable.
Doesn’t buying second-hand hurt authors and publishers?
The economics of second-hand book sales are a well-rehearsed debate. For school textbooks in India, the more relevant consideration is that NCERT books – which form the backbone of most curricula – are already publicly funded. The circular economy argument for school textbooks is distinct from the argument about new literary or professional titles, where author royalties may be at stake.
The Simplest Version of This Argument
A book is a durable object. It was designed to be read, repeatedly, by human beings who want to learn. It does not become less capable of fulfilling that purpose because one student has finished with it.
The system that turns functional books into annual waste is not a natural law. It is a design choice – made by publishers seeking annual revenue, allowed by schools with conflicting incentives, and perpetuated by the absence of any infrastructure that makes the better choice as easy as the wasteful one.
That infrastructure exists in bits and pieces, in informal groups, in local shops, in the occasional school notice board. It has never been assembled, at scale, into something reliable enough to change behaviour at the level that would actually matter.
That is the work. The books are already there. The students are already waiting. The only missing piece – for a long time – has been the organised, trusted way to connect the two.
It is being built now, one exchange at a time. And has the ‘BookMandee’.
Leave a Reply